Do service models matter for ECAs and EXIMs?

Based on their latest research, Kuno Schedler and Andreas Klasen argue that ECAs and EXIMs may benefit from analysing and innovating their service models
Kuno Schedler
Kuno Schedler
Professor, University of St Gallen
Andreas Klasen
Andreas Klasen
Visiting Professor, University of St Gallen
25/04/2023

In an extensive research project, we have assessed the application of different service models by export credit agencies (ECAs) and export-import banks (EXIMs). We conducted interviews with 35 representatives of ECAs and EXIMs from 27 countries.[1] The question guiding this study is: How do ECAs and EXIMs adopt public service models for supporting exporters? We conducted a holistic multiple case study, investigating if and how these organisations apply public service models developed by Schedler and Guenduez[2], and which roles of the state are relevant. We find that there is a variety of use of different service models by ECAs and EXIMs under consideration, and that the service model approach bears great potential to learn from each other and innovate existing services.

Service models in the public sector

Business model innovation is a key strategic concern for firms. Business models describe the architecture of a service provision (value creation), its financing (value capture) and the benefit (value proposition) achieved for the addressee.[3] In the private sector, the focus is on the ability to get ahead of the competition in a customer-centric approach. However, public administrations are generally not exposed to this fierce competition, or only to a limited extent to create a level playing field. Thus, Schedler and Guenduez are replacing the term ‘business’ with ‘service’. Nevertheless, innovations are required for the state as well, and innovative capability is a central concern of modern administrations.

The role of governments in the economy has evolved from marginal to central in the last century. With foreign trade promotion, states help firms to develop economic activities in international markets.[4] Public interventions are aimed at promoting exports and economic growth by reducing market failures and addressing market imperfections. ECAs and EXIMs offer models such as financing, insurance and guarantees, helping to provide liquidity or mitigate risks.[5] Surprisingly, a systematic analysis of which service models are used in this policy area and what roles the state plays is lacking despite the long history of officially supported export credits.

Exploring relevant roles and public service models

While exploring if ECAs and EXIMs – similar to governments in general – have a role as funders, yield shapers, performance designers, activators, and guardians of public goods (see Figure 1), our interviews suggest that ECAs and EXIMs have many models in common. In addition, they also vary to a large extent in the application of other models. It is this variety that may be a basis for interagency exchange of experience, and for innovating existing services.

Figure 1: Roles and models in public administration practices

[Based on Schedler and Guenduez, 2022]

It is not surprising that all five roles do not have the same relevance for ECAs and EXIMs in their practice. As expected, interview results reveal that some of the most relevant service models are related to the role as funder, although some of the connected models are not applied at all. All interviewees mentioned that their institution always provides de-risking instruments. Furthermore, direct lending is relevant for nearly half of the assessed ECAs and EXIMs.

On the other hand, while governments are using seed money or vouchers as a common funding service model, ECAs and EXIMs mostly do not (see Figure 2). This illustrative focus on the role of the funder clarifies the intriguing insights a service model approach can deliver.

Figure 2: ECA and EXIM service model applications as funders

Interviewees confirmed that it is the core service model of their organisations to offer post-shipment guarantees and insurance to exporters. However, a significant number of institutions have started to provide extensive pre-shipment cover solutions such as capital expenditure and working capital guarantees in the last decade. Climate-related offerings have recently become relevant. Funding offerings have broadened as well. Approximately 50% of agencies and banks in assessed countries provide direct lending.

Other models are important too!

ECAs and EXIMs focus their efforts on generating financing opportunities from their services for the fulfilment of public tasks, appearing as yield shapers. Revenue sharing, leveraging customer data and user-pays are highly relevant according to interviewees. Additionally, ECAs and EXIMs regularly act as activators. Many operate as a platform, creating network effects among exporters, foreign buyers, commercial banks, and other stakeholders.

In addition to the creation of this ‘pull’, institutions often orchestrate foreign trade activities. They coordinate the interaction of different actors in such a way that public value is created, for example for complex project finance transactions. Lastly, our results show that some service models of the performance designer role are significant for most assessed ECAs and EXIMs.

What to learn from service models?

During our discussions with experts in the field, it became clear time and again that thinking in terms of service models is not familiar. However, it is seen as increasingly exciting and profitable the more the interlocutors feel familiar with the approach.

Recognising one's own service models in a structured form is the first step. The next step is innovation: What other service models can be used to further improve the impact of one's own organisation? In doing so, the standardised models also enable comparison with other, similar organisations that perform the same tasks with other service models.



[1] Assessed countries include Australia, Belgium, Botswana, Canada, Czech Republic, Denmark, Finland, France, Germany, Hungary, Japan, Malawi, the Netherlands, New Zealand, Nigeria, Norway, Oman, Poland, South Africa, South Korea, Spain, Sweden, Switzerland, Turkey, the United Arab Emirates, the UK, and the US.

[2] Schedler, K & Guenduez, A (2022) The Service Model Navigator for the Public Sector. International Public Management Network Conference. Phoenix, AZ.

[3] Wirtz, BW, Kubin, PRM & Weyerer, JC (2023) Business model innovation in the public sector: an integrative framework. Public Management Review. 25(2), pp. 340-375.

[4] Melitz, M (2003) The Impact of Trade on Intra-Industry Reallocations and Aggregate Industry Productivity. Econometrica. 71(6), pp. 1695-1725.

[5] Jennekens, B & Klasen, A (2023) How ‘safe’ is the WTO ‘safe haven’? A need to modernise disciplines for officially supported export credits. Journal of International Trade Law and Policy. 22(1), https://doi.org/10.1108/JITLP-....

More BUlletin Publications

Celebrating 90 years of supporting trade and investment

26/02/2024

Celebrating 90 years of supporting trade and investment - 1934 - 2024

Reflecting on Berne Union’s origins and celebrating its achievements. What does the future hold?

 

Climate Working Group: The continuing momentum for change

19/09/2023

Climate Working Group: The continuing momentum for change

The Berne Union’s Climate Working Group is proving a helpful forum for sharing good practice. How is it progressing, and how can our industry continue to help with this initiative?

Claims: Controling Chaos, and Risk Versus Reality

29/06/2023

Controling Chaos, and Risk Versus Reality

In this edition we explore BU claims data and its relation to predicting risk since the pandemic, we also feature a broker's eye view of the state of the CPRI market, the bold restructuring of Denmark's investment and export financing with EIFO, how EDC is looking at ESG risks and ...

Landmark modernisation for OECD Arrangement

25/04/2023

Landmark modernisation for OECD Arrangement

A bold agreement for the Arrangement marks a positive development for our industry. Also featuring
digital access to export finance for China SMEs, challenging the 'China debt trap' narrative for Africa,
insolvency trends, analysing service ...

What's on the horizon for 2023?

28/02/2023

What's on the horizon for 2023?

The pick of key issues to look out for in 2023 – from macro trends, potentially choppy seas for smaller ECAs,  possibilities for using Islamic finance in the renewable energy transition, China’s reopening, a bumpy CPRI outlook, and reinsurance complexities. 

Authors look at...

Digitalisation as a business leadership imperative

25/11/2022

Digitalisation as a business leadership imperative

Technology-driven trade and client interaction are nothing new. But increasing investment in digitalisation of fundamental business processes and decision making is driving a new way of looking at trade finance and risk underwriting. Authors highlight successes and challen...

Mobilising Africa's Potential

06/09/2022

Mobilising Africa's Potential

Despite the challenges there are many positive opportunities emerging for Africa today

Curated by the BU Sub-Saharan Africa Working Group, authors for this special edition of the BUlletin explore areas of growth and the role of different sources of international finance tapping this

Ripples and After-effects

22/07/2022

Ripples and After-effects

exploring the multiple secondary impacts of both the pandemic and the war in Ukraine

from sovereign risk in Africa, to energy security, political violence and the private CPRI market

Shocks and Short Circuits: The Rewiring of Global Trade

07/04/2022

Shocks and short-circuits: The re-wiring of global trade

The bright shoots of economic growth are under threat once again
Assailed by commodity supply shocks and political instability exacerbated by the war in Ukraine
Contributors this month look at the complex impacts on trade and investment across developed and...

Diverging Risk

14/01/2022

Some predict that 2022 may finally bring us beyond the thrall of the COVID-19 pandemic

But the events of past two years have brought significant divergence of risk across economic and geographic boundaries

Authors this month look at how this is playing out in a range of cases

New Foundations

29/09/2021

If the global economy is truly on the road to recovery how can we build the surest path to sustainable growth in our new net-zero world?

New foundations in tech, data, and cooperative frameworks may help guide us into the next phase

Illuminating Climate

22/07/2021

Now widely recognised as an economic as well as environmental imperative
The momentum to tackle climate change is building
Changing perspectives, policy, products and processes across the export credit industry

In search of claims

30/04/2021

Where is the avalanche of claims and insolvencies expected to emerge from COVID-19?
The picture so far is uneven across geographies, sectors and business lines
And for the future? Well, it depends...

Cross-roads for Africa's recovery

21/04/2021

The economic impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on Africa has been considerable and the path of recovery depends on maintaining the support of local, regional and international stakeholders. But which approaches can best build upon the opportunities presented by growing intra-regional trade, and investment in sustainable infrastructure?

Navigating the Brave New World of Trade

23/03/2021

With the wounds of the pandemic still under triage, a rebound in trade could the best hope for governments and businesses alike.
But trade is under immense pressure from myriad directions.
How can we maintain supply of finance, in the face of growing demand and irregular patterns of risk?